August 05, 2024 | Business Strategy | M&A | Data Analytics | CFO | By Shikhar Saxena
Introduction
In today's dynamic business landscape, a robust merger and acquisition (M&A) strategy plays a crucial role in driving growth, expanding market share, and enhancing competitive advantage. Developing a merger and acquisition strategy requires a blend of strategic foresight, data-driven decision-making, and stakeholder alignment. This article, inspired by our latest work with the CFO office of a fast-casual restaurant chain to buy back franchisee locations, explores key considerations and best practices for crafting an effective M&A strategy that can be applied across various industries to drive sustainable growth.
1. Establish clear objectives for your merger and acquisition strategy
Before embarking on any merger and acquisition activity, it's crucial to define clear objectives that align with your company's overall growth strategy. These objectives might include:
Expanding market share
Entering new geographic markets
Acquiring new technologies or capabilities
Achieving economies of scale
Diversifying product or service offerings
By clearly articulating these objectives, you create a foundation for evaluating potential acquisition targets and ensuring all stakeholders are aligned on the strategic vision. For our client, the focus was to grow the brand while sustaining brand quality. This helped us establish the right qualifying criteria for the potential acquisition targets.
2. Develop a bottom-up, data-driven approach
In the era of big data, successful M&A strategies leverage advanced analytics to inform decision-making. Key steps in developing a data-driven approach include:
a) Identify Relevant Metrics: Determine the key performance indicators (KPIs) that will guide your acquisition decisions. These may include financial metrics (e.g., revenue, EBITDA, profit margins) and operational metrics specific to your industry.
In our case, we looked at certain parameters such as Prime Cost (COGS + Labor costs) and Rent, which are crucial for operational efficiency in the restaurant industry. We also considered qualitative data on the real estate of target locations - up to 16 variables such as type of location, seating capacity, parking availability, trade area quality, etc. – which are crucial to store performance.
b) Collect and Analyze Data: Gather comprehensive data on potential acquisition targets, including financial performance, market position, customer base, and operational efficiency.
c) Utilize Advanced Analytics: Employ sophisticated analytical techniques such as predictive modeling, machine learning, and scenario analysis to gain deeper insights into potential acquisitions. We conducted Regression and Random Forests analyses to identify the most relevant real estate parameters impacting the sales performance of the stores.
Our developed strategy provided the client with a clear, data-driven framework to prioritize franchisee store acquisitions. We incorporated both quantitative data (enhanced through subjective business understanding) and qualitative data (verified through objective statistical analyses). This rigorous approach ensured that no relevant data point or perspective was missed in building the acquisition model.
3. Create a scoring model to streamline decision-making
While not necessarily a part of every approach, we found that developing a robust scoring model helped to prioritize and rank our potential acquisition targets, especially since we were considering ~300 individual store locations. This model helped us to:
Incorporate both quantitative and qualitative factors
Assign appropriate weights to different criteria based on their importance to your strategic objectives
Allow for flexibility to adjust weights as market conditions or company priorities change
We combined the financial and real estate parameters into a singular model to assign Attractiveness and Cost of Acquisition scores using our Business Value Rating (BVR) assessment. When visualized on a 2x2 grid, the BVR assessment helps to prioritize and rank each store’s acquisition.
4. Leverage technology to support decision-making
Implement advanced tools and technologies to support your M&A strategy:
Data visualization platforms to present complex information in an easily digestible format
Real-time dashboards for monitoring key metrics and market trends
Collaboration tools to facilitate communication among stakeholders
Utilizing PowerBI, we created a visual dashboard for the leadership to view the acquisition opportunities on the BVR grid and ascertain the prioritization and ranking of acquisition opportunities with a glance. Providing various perspectives on the same location – review status, sales variance %, location risk categories, sales cohorts, and NPV – allows the leadership to take a more nuanced approach to their merger and acquisition strategy. Tweaking the input values in the model results in real-time updates on the dashboard, allowing the leadership to test out different strategies at the same time.
5. Build flexibility into your approach
The business landscape is constantly evolving. Ensure your merger and acquisition strategy remains flexible enough to adapt to changing market conditions, emerging opportunities, and potential risks.
Our client, who previously lacked the ability to make data-driven and methodical decisions regarding their merger and acquisition strategy, now benefits from a robust model that supports sustainable growth through quick decision-making. The flexibility of the model is demonstrated through the ability to change the weights which determine the relative importance of each attribute, prompting an instant update in the BVR score as well as acquisition price. This allows the leadership to adjust their acquisition strategy based on shifting internal priorities and external drivers.
Another notable example of the model’s flexibility was the swift development of an acquisition strategy for a competitor. By loading the competitor's store locations data, both publicly available and through specialized research tools, we could swap out irrelevant attributes with those suitable for an external acquisition. The resulting analysis was in line with the client's estimates, which helped cement a strong sense of confidence in the model. The speed of analysis was key in being able to present the business case in front of the Board of Directors within a week. This further established the robustness and versatility of our model.
6. Plan for integration post merger/acquisition
A successful merger and acquisition strategy extends beyond the acquisition itself. Develop a comprehensive plan for post-merger integration that addresses:
Organizational structure and leadership
Systems and process integration
Cultural alignment
Communication strategy for employees, customers, and other stakeholders
Challenges and Solutions
No matter how structured the strategy is, challenges and issues are always present. In our case, we faced some of the challenges listed below:
Data Complexity: Managing extensive data sets and performing complex statistical analyses were critical to ensuring accurate parameter identification. Our iterative approach and use of advanced analytical techniques helped us navigate these complexities effectively.
Addressing Model Bias: The initial data analysis using linear regression had a low accuracy. To improve it, we addressed potential biases through various techniques such as considering multicollinearity and scaling/regularizing the data. Ultimately, we chose to apply Random Forest over regression due to its ability to handle nonlinear relationships, manage a large number of features, and provide higher accuracy.
Stakeholder Buy-In: Ensuring alignment with leadership and PE advisors was crucial, considering the at-times differing agendas and perspectives. Through continuous collaboration, validation phases, and transparent communication, we successfully garnered the necessary support and confidence for the proposed strategy.
Conclusion
Crafting a robust merger and acquisition strategy involves strategic planning, thorough data analysis, and stakeholder collaboration. Our approach exemplifies how a structured approach can effectively guide business expansion in a competitive market. By leveraging sophisticated analytical techniques and fostering strong stakeholder relationships, businesses can navigate economic challenges while achieving sustained growth.
About Us
Our story began with the deep desire to drive tangible, visible, and measurable outcomes for clients. With that as our guiding beacon, we launched Gravitas Consulting – a boutique consulting firm specializing in bringing Insight to Oversight.
We help our clients scale and improve their businesses by the thoughtful application of Intelligent Information to guide decisions and actions. We leverage our data analytics and visualization, enterprise program and change management, and customer experience design expertise to provide leaders with the intelligence they need to do what they do best, even better.
At Gravitas, we measure success by only one metric: each client’s satisfaction with our ability to drive Outcomes that matter. We stand behind this belief by putting a portion of our fees at risk if we do not meet the commitments we promise.
Our promise to clients is simple: we drive outcomes that matter.